• Home
  • About
  • Clinic
  • Training
  • Tenants
  • Landlord Law

The Landlord Law Blog

From landlord and tenant lawyer Tessa Shepperson

  • Home
  • Posts
  • News & comment
  • Cases
  • Tenants
    • The Renters Guide Website
    • 15 Places for tenant help
  • Clinic
  • Series
    • Analysis
    • should law and justice be free
    • HMO Basics
    • Tenancy Agreements 33 days
    • Airbnb
    • Grounds for Eviction
    • Tips

New case on unfair terms in tenancy agreements

June 27, 2013 by Tessa J Shepperson

law caseNew cases on the unfair terms regulations are quite rare – those from the European Court even more so. So its very interesting to have a European decision.

Brusse and Garabito v Jahani Ltd [2013] EUECJ C-488/11

30 May 2013

This is a case from the Netherlands.  It concerns a residential tenancy where the tenants believed that the penalty clauses for unpaid rent were unfair as they did not reflect the actual loss to the landlords.

The case was referred to the European Court on the interpretation of the regulations.  Despite being Dutch, this case is binding on us as it is on the general interpretation of the regulations, which apply to all countries subject to the EEC law.

The case clarifies a number of points as follows:

When the regulations apply

The unfair terms regulations will apply

to a residential tenancy agreement concluded between a landlord acting for purposes relating to his trade, business or profession and a tenant acting for purposes which do not relate to his trade, business or profession

This begs the question, what about lets where the landlord is not a professional landlord?

Probably an agreement made between someone renting their house out while they work abroad for a year (for example) will be exempt, although the general view is that this will not be the case if they are using a letting agent and the agents’ standard tenancy agreement is used.

The duty of the court

The court has a duty to consider any contract terms which are in dispute ‘of its own motion’ (which means that it must do it anyway, not just if the point is raised by one of the parties) and annul any terms which it thinks are unfair.

This is just the terms of the contact which are ‘in dispute’ however – they don’t have to go through the whole tenancy agreement looking for unfair terms.

Penalty clauses

The final question was about whether a national court can change the penalty under a tenancy agreement to make it fair.

The decision was that, no, it can’t do this.  It must annul the clause altogether.

So if you have an ‘unfair’ penalty clause, and this is the subject of court proceedings (perhaps if you are suing your tenant for rent arrears plus the penalty), a court must consider whether this clause is fair or not.

If the court decides it is not fair, then it will be as if the clause was not there and you will not be able to claim under it.

If you have penalty clauses in your tenancy agreement therefore, you may want to take a look at them and amend them if they could be considered unfair.

Thanks to Garden Court Chambers Housing law bulletin for alerting me to this case.  You can read the full decision on BAILII here.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: Law case report

Scroll down for the comments

IMPORTANT: Please check the date of the post above - remember, if it is an old post, the law may have changed since it was written.

You should always get independent legal advice before taking any action.

Notes on comments:

For personal landlord and tenant related problems, please use our >> Blog Clinic.
Note that we do not publish all comments, please >> click here to read our terms of use and comments policy. Comments close after three months.

Keep up with the news on Landlord Law blog!

To get posts sent direct to your email in box click here

About Tessa J Shepperson

Tessa is a specialist landlord & tenant lawyer and the creator of this site! She is a director of Landlord Law Services which runs Landlord Law and Easy Law Training.

« Does a tenant HAVE to sign a new fixed term tenancy?
Ben reeve Lewis Friday newsround #112 »

Comments

  1. Ben Reeve Lewis says

    June 28, 2013 at 8:56 AM

    Now this is a very interesting development Tessa. Claims of this kind are quite common. We currently have a landlord claiming £1,500 interest for 15 days without rent.

    The big bugbear of course is the issue about professional landlords. This particular guy doesnt use an agent but we know of 5 or 6 properties that he rents out. It would be interesting to see how the court treat this when we go in the tenant’s defence

  2. Industry Observer says

    July 1, 2013 at 1:15 PM

    Hi Ben

    Isn’t this sort of thing usury, and basically in contradiction with The Moneylenders Act whenever that was?

“Interesting posts on residential landlord & tenant law and practice - in England & Wales UK”

Subscribe to the Landlord Law Blog by email

Never miss another post!

Sign up to our
>> daily updates

If you are new to the blog >> click here

Get Your Free Ebook:

Click to get your Free Ebook

>> Click Here for Your Free Copy

Featured Post

Tessa Shepperson

Why you need and how to get proper legal advice on landlord and tenant issues

Tessa’s Podcast

The Landlord and Lawyer Podcast

Worried about Insurance?

Landlord Law Insurance Mini-Course

Disclaimer

The purpose of this blog is to provide information, comment and discussion.

Although Tessa, or guest bloggers, may from time to time, give helpful comments to readers' questions, these can only be based on the information given by the reader in his or her comment, which may not contain all material facts.

Any comments or suggestions provided by Tessa or any guest bloggers should not, therefore be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice from a qualified lawyer regarding any actual legal issue or dispute.

Nothing on this website should be construed as legal advice or perceived as creating a lawyer-client relationship (apart from the Fast Track block clinic service - so far as the questioners only are concerned).

Please also note that any opinion expressed by a guest blogger is his or hers alone, and does not necessarily reflect the views of Tessa Shepperson, or the other writers on this blog.

Cookies

You can find out more about our use of 'cookies' on this website here.

Associated sites

Landlord Law Services
The Renters Guide
Eco Landlords
Your Law Store

Legal

Landlord Law Blog is © 2006 – 2021 Tessa Shepperson.

Note that Tessa is an introducer for Alan Boswell Insurance Brokers and will get a commission from sales made via links on this website.

© 2006–2022 Tessa Shepperson | Rainmaker Platform | Contact Page | Privacy | Log in

This website or its third-party tools use cookies which are necessary to its functioning and required to improve your experience. By clicking the consent button, you agree to allow the site to use, collect and/or store cookies.
I accept